Pulmonary hypertension (PH) is a hemodynamic condition defined by a mean pulmonary artery pressure of > 25 mm Hg at rest as measured by right heart catheterization. Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is PH with a normal pulmonary capillary wedge pressure or left ventricular end diastolic pressure without structural cardiac, pulmonary parenchymal, pulmonary vascular, or thrombotic disease.1 PH contributes to patient symptoms, is a marker of disease severity, and increases morbidity and mortality in many of the diseases it complicates. Additionally, PH has the capacity to affect pre- and posttransplant survival in patients requiring solid organ transplantation. Prior reviews have addressed the frequency of lung transplantation as a treatment for PAH and the adverse impact of the Lung Allocation Score on lung transplant access for these patients and on posttransplant outcomes in those who do undergo lung transplantation.2,3 This review will concentrate on those patients with other lung diseases and other end-stage organ diseases that can be complicated by PH.
Lung Diseases Complicated by Pulmonary Hypertension
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
One of the most common causes of death in the United States is chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). According to the American Lung Association, COPD is the third-leading cause of U.S. deaths,4 and patients with COPD represent about one-third of all lung transplant recipients.5 A meta-analysis of 10 papers reviewing COPD and hemodynamically confirmed PH concluded that very high pulmonary artery (PA) pressures were relatively rare, that exercise provoked substantial increases in PA pressure, and that survival was inversely proportional to pulmonary vascular resistance.6 The authors emphasized the importance of treatment that focused on the underlying disease statefor example, treating COPD with bronchodilators and oxygen therapy. A review of 4,305 COPD lung transplant candidates from May 2005 compared those with PH (defined as either PA mean > 25 or > 35) to propensity score-matched candidates without PH. Using either definition of PH, there was a significant decrease in survival probability that was both clinically and statistically significant (HR of 3.4 for mortality with PH 35 95 CI 2.410, 4.888 P < .001).7 In another cohort of COPD patients who survived to lung transplant, the presence of pretransplant PH was defined by an increase in transpulmonary gradient (TPG), which is the difference between PA mean and wedge pressure (with normal being < 12). COPD patients so characterized as having PH had a 1.74-times higher risk of 1-year posttransplant mortality (P .001), and this relationship increased at higher levels of TPG. In these COPD patients, a TPG greater than 28 mm Hg conferred a 2-fold increase in relative risk for death compared to COPD patients without PH.8 Interestingly, this impact of PH on posttransplant mortality described in this study was not observed in patients with cystic fibrosis or idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.
Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis
The incidence of PH in patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is variably described from 8 to 86 depending on the method used to assess PH (echocardiography or heart catheterization) and the timing of the hemodynamic assessment relative to the time of the transplant and disease duration (Figure 1).9,10 An interventional study that attempted to evaluate the noninvasive predictors of hemodynamically proven PH demonstrated that the presence of PH is best predicted by parameters derived from formal exercise testing (VE vs VCO2 slope and peak VO2). What was most important, however, was that the authors demonstrated that pre-transplant survival was severely impaired in IPF patients with PH.
In contrast to what was seen in patients with COPD, the presence of PH in patients with a diagnosis of IPF does not appear to confer a survival risk after transplant.8,11 The issue, then, with patients with IPF and PH is whether or not there is a place for pretransplant treatment with PAH disease-modifying medications. Multiple studies done with endothelin receptor antagonists (macitentan, bosentan, and ambrisentan) have been uniformly negative, and in some cases the data have suggested the potential for irreversible disease worsening.
Similar studies done with phosphodiesterase inhibitors have shown modest improvements in hemodynamics but worsening brain natriuretic peptide levels (suggesting ventricular overload) as well as worsening 6-minute walk test (6MWT) results.12 A 12-week study in 180 IPF patients randomized to placebo or sildenafil failed to meet the primary end point of improvement in effort tolerance as measured by the 6MWT; however, there were some encouraging though nonsignificant trends toward improvement in other physiological measures and symptom scores.13
Liver Disease and Pulmonary Hypertension
Pulmonary hypertension is variably reported to occur in 2 to 101 of cirrhotic patients and in as many as 16 of patients with advanced liver disease considered for liver transplantation.14,15 The histological appearance of the plexiform lesions seen in patients with severe portopulmonary hypertension are indistinguishable on H&E staining from classical PAH.16 A review of patients undergoing liver transplantation in the face of varying degrees of PH demonstrated 100 mortality in those with a mean PA pressure > 50 mm Hg and 50 mortality in those with a mean PA pressure between 35 and 49.17 In addition, data from the REVEAL registry have demonstrated that patients with newly diagnosed portopulmonary hypertension have a significantly worse survival (57 8 at 24 months) compared to individuals with idiopathic PAH whether newly or previously diagnosed (82 2 vs 86 1, respectively).18
In patients undergoing liver transplantation with a prior diagnosis of portopulmonary hypertension, and having received standardized Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) exception points for this diagnosis and its treatment, there is an increased risk of both death and graft failure (HR 2.25 and 1.96, respectively) in the first year after liver transplant compared to those without portopulmonary hypertension.19 This substantial risk may be due to lack of adherence to the carefully defined requirements for resolution and adequacy of hemodynamics prior to transplantation.20 Hence, the presence of PH in those with liver disease confers an increased risk of mortality with or without transplant.
It is important to recognize that liver transplant recipients are probably the sickest patients to undergo organ transplant. Though PH confers additional risk, this should be considered in the context of a 23.4 mortality rate in liver failure patients within the ICU at time of transplant, and a 1.54-fold risk of death within 3 months of transplant in patients with a MELD score of > 35 compared to those with a MELD score between 30 and 34 at transplant.
Pulmonary Hypertension in End-Stage Renal Disease
In the first prospective study of PH in U.S. patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD), all patients at a single center underwent echocardiograms prospectively.21 Of the 90 total patients, 47 met echocardiographic criteria for PH (tricuspid regurgitant jet > 2.5 m/s) and 20 had severe PH (tricuspid regurgitant jet > 3.0 m/s); mortality in those with echocardiographic evidence of severe PH was 26 compared to 6 in those without PH. Echocardiographic findings were consistent with left ventricular and fluid overload as the cause of PH.21
Consistent with the premise that left heart disease is a major risk factor for PH in this patient population is the observation that systemic hypertension is more frequent in ESRD patients with PH than in those without PH (33 vs 15).22 Additionally, PH also impacted transplant outcomes in ESRD patients. Among patients receiving a living donor kidney, early graft dysfunction was not observed regardless of PH status. However, in patients receiving a deceased donor kidney, those with PH had a significant increased risk of early graft dysfunction versus those without PH (56 vs 11.7, P .01).22 Univariate and multivariable logistic regression supported this observation as an independent risk factor beyond potentially confounding recipient, donor, and graft-based risk factors for early graft dysfunction (P < .05).23
An extensive review of survival following renal transplant defined pretransplant PH by the echocardiographic estimate of right ventricular systolic pressure (RVSP).23 Out of 215 patients, 68 had normal RVSP (< 35 mm Hg), 22 had mild to moderately elevated RVSP (3650 mm Hg), and 10 had markedly elevated RVSP (> 50 mm Hg) suggestive of severe PH. Time on dialysis was the strongest correlate of an elevated RVSP (r .253, P < .001).23 An RVSP greater than 50 was associated with significantly reduced posttransplant survival (HR 3.75, 1.1711.97; P .016). This relationship was independent of other variables including older age, reduced left ventricular ejection fraction, low serum albumin, and delayed graft function.
Given that the data regarding time on dialysis is found to be predictive of pretransplant PH, and given the association of systemic hypertension and PH in the ESRD patient population, it is reasonable to predict that PH can also arise de novo following a renal transplant. Numerous studies suggest that PH occurs post-transplant in 5 to 14 of patients. A review of the frequency of de novo PH after renal transplant demonstrated that it occurred in 8 of 100 renal transplants and was associated with higher renal resistive index, higher C-reactive protein, and higher pulse wave velocityall features of chronic injury and vascular stiffness.24 The features of right ventricular dysfunction and PH in patients with ESRD being considered for renal transplantation are highly predictive for both all-cause and cardiovascular mortality following transplantation.25
Pulmonary Hypertension in Left Heart Disease
Pulmonary hypertension is a frequent complication of chronic left heart disease/failure. Irrespective of the causebe it left ventricular systolic dysfunction, diastolic dysfunction, or valvular abnormalitiespulmonary artery pressure will be disproportionately elevated in about one-third of cases. This may be a genetically determined response to chronic pressure or flow changes in the pulmonary vascular bed that results in a histological appearance similar to that seen in idiopathic PH. Despite the similarities to idiopathic PH, currently available drug therapies for PAH have been universally unsuccessful in mitigating PH due to left-sided heart disease.
Attempts to perform transplants on heart failure patients with PH were associated with increased mortality.26 Patients with a PA systolic pressure > 50 mm Hg associated with an elevated transpulmonary gradient (TPG > 16 mm Hg) suffered a 50 operative mortality rate with cardiac transplant. The higher the PA systolic pressure and the TPG or pulmonary regurgitant velocity, the greater the perioperative mortality. The presence of a pretransplant vasodilator response did not impact mortality.26 Consequently, the current standard of practice is to use a left ventricular assist device (LVAD), biventricular assist device, or total artificial heart to bridge a patient to transplant. Biventricular assist devices probably represent about 20 to 50 of VAD recipients waiting for transplant. Based on this, current studies are looking at PAH-specific therapy to facilitate normalization of regurgitant velocity by acting on the pulmonary vascular bed in these VAD recipients.
Pulmonary hypertension is a frequent complication of both pulmonary and nonpulmonary organ failure. When present, it is a marker of disease severity and associated with higher mortality. It also complicates or prevents solid organ transplant by conferring either immediate perioperative mortality (as is the case in liver and heart transplant) or an increased risk of early graft dysfunction and long-term mortality (as in kidney failure). Though specific therapies for PAH are useful in liver disease, they have not proven useful in heart, kidney, or lung disease where such therapies can in fact be deleterious.
- Pulmonary hypertension is a frequent complication of both pulmonary and nonpulmonary organ failure and is a marker of disease severity.
- PH contributes to patient symptoms and increases morbidity and mortality in many of the diseases it complicates, such as end-stage renal disease, liver disease, and heart failure.
- PH can affect pre- and posttransplant survival in patients requiring solid organ transplantation.